Instructor Presence in Educational Video

Wpływ obrazu nauczyciela w edukacyjnych materiałach wideo na przyswajanie wiedzy

The Researcher

Yen Ying Ng

Yen Ying Ng

PhD Student
Nicolaus Copernicus University

I am a PhD student at Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland, working at the intersection of AI in education, distance learning, and linguistics.

My research focuses on how people learn from digital materials—especially educational videos and language-learning resources. In the Pearls of Science project presented on this page, I examined how different instructor-on-screen formats influence learning and attention in beginner Mandarin vocabulary learning.

In parallel, I am developing speech-recognition approaches that could provide learners with automated feedback on both sound and tone correctness in Mandarin Chinese, with the longer-term goal of supporting scalable online learning.

Supervisor Prof. Sławomir Wacewicz Nicolaus Copernicus University
Funding Program "Perły Nauki" 🇵🇱 Ministry of Science and Higher Education
Project Period 2023-06-06 to 2025-12-06
Project No. PN/01/0232/2022
Total Project Value 142,164 PLN
Project Page (PL) View on UMK Website

Project Background

Educational videos are central to blended learning, flipped classrooms, and MOOCs. Yet, the field still debates whether showing the instructor helps learning.

There is a theoretical conflict between the Cognitive-Affective-Social Theory (CASTLE), which suggests a visible teacher enhances motivation, and Cognitive Load Theory (CLT), which argues a visible teacher acts as a distraction.

This research project investigates this conflict in the specific context of Mandarin Chinese vocabulary learning. By utilizing eye-tracking technology, we measured visual attention patterns to determine if the "talking head" format helps students learn tonal languages or simply splits their attention.

Project Tasks

Task 1. Systematic Literature Review

We synthesized prior work on instructor presence in educational videos, focusing on learning outcomes, attention processes, and cognitive load-related findings.

  • Search and screening across major databases
  • Final set of coded studies: 51
  • Manuscript currently under review in Review of Education

Task 2. Study Preparation & Data Collection

We prepared three video variants (no instructor / continuous / intermittent) and conducted a matched-groups, two-session study with eye tracking and speaking tests.

  • No Instructor: Voice-over narration with only slides visible.
  • Continuous: The instructor's face is visible throughout the entire lesson.
  • Intermittent: The instructor appears only during non-critical segments to reduce distraction.

Task 3. Analysis (Learning + Eye Tracking)

We linked learning outcomes (speaking test) with objective gaze data to assess whether instructor presence changes performance, attention allocation, and cognitive-load indicators.

  • Statistical modelling in R (mixed-effects approach)
  • Outcome: no clear performance advantage of any format
  • Disseminated at ISD’25 (paper published)

Task 4. Automation Pilot (Pronunciation Scoring)

We tested whether a cloud speech-to-text service could support automatic scoring of recorded responses. Agreement with expert ratings was moderate and uneven across participants.

  • Prototype: Python + Google Speech-to-Text
  • Average agreement with expert ratings: ~70%
  • Conclusion: not recommended as a replacement in this setting

Key Findings

Learning outcomes

We did not observe a statistically meaningful advantage of continuous or intermittent instructor presence over the no-instructor format for short-term vocabulary learning outcomes.

Visual attention

Across formats, learners primarily attended to Pinyin. The instructor tended to be a secondary visual element, supporting the idea that attention shifts do not automatically lead to better performance.

Cognitive load (objective indicators)

Eye-tracking-based indicators did not provide strong evidence that any instructor format consistently reduced cognitive processing demands compared to the others in this specific lesson setting.

Practical implication

For short vocabulary videos, an instructor-absent design is a robust default: it maintains effectiveness while reducing production complexity and simplifying post-production edits.

Dissemination & Publications

Poster Presentation | ISESS 2024
Systematic Review of Eye Tracking Studies
Presented at the 5th International Symposium on Education, Economics, Psychology and Social Sciences.
Title: A Systematic Review of Eye Tracking Studies on the Impact of Instructor Presence in Educational Videos.
View Poster
Published | ISD 2025
The Impact of Instructor Presence Formats on Learning Outcomes...
Ng, Y.Y., Placiński, M. & Szala, A. (2025). The Impact of Instructor Presence Formats on Learning Outcomes, Visual Attention, and Cognitive Load in Educational Videos: An Eye-Tracking Study. ISD 2025 Proceedings.
View DOI
Under Review
Systematic Literature Review Manuscript
Submitted to the journal Review of Education. This manuscript details the synthesis of 51 prior studies on instructor presence.
Oral Presentation | DSD 2025
DSD 2025 Conference Presentation
An extended analysis of the eye-tracking data and cognitive load metrics was presented at DSD'25.
View Presentation Slides